I teach children computer stuff (any kind of creative tinkering on a computer that I can help them out with). Currently we’re using Renoise (among other things) if they want to start producing music, because it’s (1) the only decent music producing software out there which is at least somewhat functional in the free demo version (it’s volunteer work, we don’t have much budget) and (2) by now I know how to use it pretty well (though 1 was the reason I started learning Renoise in the first place, great decision in hindsight, with my demoscene background and love for low-level DSP tinkering, I might not even be making music today).
Anyway, if you don’t work with children (or have children yourself) it might be hard to estimate what kids of a certain age can and can’t do.
Let me say this, there’s no way a five year old kid can use Renoise on their own without supervision and constant (yes, constant) help. Not saying this story is entirely untrue (although AFX is well-known for making up ridiculous shit during interviews), but if it is, he’s had to have sat with his son during production 100% of the time. If it’s a 9-year old (mayyybe 7-8 if they’re super clever prodigies, I’ve seen them), you could cut that down to 75%. When they get older (again, depending on abilities and talent, but in general from 11-12 onwards, assuming they’re motivated) you can leave them alone most of the time, only prompted when they need something new, have a specific question (or I just feel they need a slight nudge in the right direction) (great exercise in practising restraint, for myself :P).
Renoise, in all its awesomeness, is really quite a pretty hard piece of software to learn for children. Now my kids have a slight disadvantage, being Dutch, and at that age they can hardly read English, but on the other hand, Renoise doesn’t have that much words in its interface, and the parts that are, are probably quite technical for native English kids as well. It’s just a very dense interface (which for me, also makes it so awesome).
But even if the kid is a genius child-prodigy who happens to have RDJ as a teacher.
Fact of the matter is, language or intelligence aside, 5-year old kids don’t even yet possess the motor-skills to use a mouse properly (at least in my experience: 6 or 7, and they need a lot of practice–then, half a year later they’re suddenly masters at it. But not a 5-year old, no way). Let alone a typing keyboard. This is one of the reasons why tablets are so brilliant. Even 3-year olds grok them immediately (I’ve heard a charming story about a 3-year old that loved playing with her parents’ tablet, at some point being given a glossy magazine, she tried to swipe it, got angry because this thing was obviously defective, hahaha! welcome to THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY).
Now this makes me wonder though, if the story is at least partially true, it means RDJ has had to sit with his son producing music in Renoise all the way, explaining it to him and most importantly simply taking care of all the tiny details (simply navigating a filesystem to find instruments or samples is quite a challenge for most kids–especially if they’re used to tablets or other devices that tend to hide this nowadays). And that means our beloved AFX must be quite skilled in Renoise himself? Otherwise why would he recommend it to his son? IMO there’s music software out there that’s way more intuitive for young children than the hexadecimal Renoise, even Fruityloops. and unlike me, Aphex can afford, too–so it’s a weird choice even if AFX is an avid Renoise user himself. Kinda makes me doubt the whole story. If I had a 5yo kid, and money, I wanted to teach music, sorry but that’s just not what Renoise is good at. It’s best at geeking around over little details, which is what I love about it, a joy of which is something children don’t quite discover until they’re 12 or 13 (pay attention to the difference of stuff they build in Minecraft, for instance). After that though, some of them turn into true Hackers. Beautiful.