Thank you both very much - let me see if I can justify myself.
Overall what I am seeing is that it appears some Thor controls (possibly other Reason instruments) are either not listed in the midi controller chart or are incorrect - the actual controls may have changed over time.
One way I can show you is if you have Reason.
First open Renoise 2.1 B4 (so it is the master), then open up the midi controller chart and finally Reason.
Next, add Thor in Reason.
One of the first Thor controller values listed in the chart is for “Osc 1 + 2 Level”. In Thor, right-click on the “1 + 2” fader level for the osciallator mixer control that sits between Filter 1 and Filter 2. Select “Edit Remote Override Mapping”. The heading for this item will be displayed at the top, and it should say “Item: Thor - Osc 1 And 2 Level”.
Now switch to Renoise. Add a ReWire-In Device, then go to Instrument settings and and select the midi device “ReWire: Reason - Thor 1”. Now add the Midi-Controller Device. For the first CC drop down, in the list you will see “Osc 1 And 2 Level”. If you select it and adjust the slider, you should see this control affect the expected item in Reason.
Now go back to Thor, and for the first Oscillator choose the “FM Pair Osc”. Right click in the box that starts at “1” for the Carrier waveform and select “Edit Remote Override Mapping”. Here you see this item is called “Item: Thor 1 - Osc 1 Param B”. The Mod waveform is called “Item: Thor 1 - Osc 1 Param C”. However, you wil also notice these values to show in the midi controller document.
The only reason I bring the keyboard into the equation, is that it allowed me to prove to myself that these are valid contollable items in Thor that can be mapped to - I have done it and it works.
The other thing I want to point out, is that the item name specified must be exact - while the midi controller document says the oscillator level 1 and 2 value is “Osc 1 + 2 Level”, if you try to call it by that name it won’t work - you can see this one is correct in Renoise.
If you guys have signed up as devs on Reason site, I wonder if they have information about this or you can ask them about it - not sure. Is it poss possible for someone else to confirm this information as well?
I love the way both Renoise and Reason allow me to write music, each for their different bits of awesomeness. I am incredibly excited that Renoise is adding ReWire, and I would love for these things to work as well as possible - half my time creating the right sounds, the rest actually writing the tune.
If need be, I will determine what every valid controller value is for every instrument and object in Reason and send it your way.
Does this all make sense? Please let me know if you need any more details or information, and again, thank you very much!