So much tunes, I’d like to thank everyone for 2hrs of playtime variety The experimental/idm vain is strong in this one. My 2 cents about the tracks (I’ve marked my picks with +) - Please let me know if I omitted someone!:
00.1daemonarmada/roy robinson in dreams
I like how the guitar parts switch to piano parts. The overall dissonance mood makes this track cool.
VaeprismAbyssus/unfurnished mutant
Fantastic use of household percussion in sound design.
BasicMethods/2016mb9
Really solid deep/underground house. I think the structure is good, but maybe some variation on chords or parts without chords would be beneficial here to improve interest.
Burital/Robochip
I like the chiptune/beastieboys combo, the breakparts are equally nice too. Why there is no bass/bassline? The main riff is good, but it would also benefit from some other supporting parts like pads, etc.
Carbonthief/SecurityDeposit
Im not the big fan of GMesque quality of some sounds but the track is very well thought out. Neat guitars.
Chunter/ThisYourHomeNow
Interesting intro and the overall minimalistic atmosphere. I liked the progressions and vocal parts. Everything souded soo dry and sterile, at least for my taste.
CrashNoiseDivision/MustSleepInTub
Song with a realy great mood. I wish there was a little bit more substance to this one.
Danoise/Glixxando (+)
Gotta love those strings, they define this track for me. Sold and polished one, theres not much to brag about, I think maybe the bass department is the weakest part here (needs more compelling and clear bassline, at least imo).
JTPE/Mudslingage
Interesting drum variations.I think there are also some nice fx here and there.
EatMe/ItsHotInHere
Nice vibe and the best sounding key/pad in mbc9. Both of the chord progressions parts are well done here. I wished they were more distant from each other, for the overall contrast to be bigger. Also no other distractions, like fx, arps etc. so it got slightly boring at the end.
Ester/SidAM3-4
Well made IDM piece, done by numbers (I am really not an expert on this at all, but mangled amens on top of reminscent pads/erratic rhodes/ grained-streched vocals sounds pretty familiar).
ffx/NeverStopMovingOn
Another very solid 80s vibe track with great sounds. Arrangement wise I think track maybe unnecesarily streches above 4 minutes, since there is almost nothing new there and the breakdown with the bass was weird to me.
Geteon/AffordableHousing
Fine chiptune and glitchy parts in short form, but that wall of sound was an overkill for me.
JBL/MotherNeptune
Great atmosphere and sounds. I would really liked a longer form.
Komu/Freedom
All the melodic parts and the arrangement were pretty good. Didn’t liked the overly bright and dry sound of drums and the vowel part was a bit too cheesy for me.
kurtzlapiNIC/Shelefttheaparment
That was definitely too much of vowel filter for me :). I think the melodies were nice.
Mars64/MutantBreakz9
Pretty decent jungle tune. The occasional ‘wet’ bass parts felt a bit too loud.
Matt DeMoss/ExpansionPort
Not much to say about this one, other that sound wise it was pretty great, I love chiptunes.
Michal79/StillNotHome
Something went wrong with the bassline after 2:17? Loved the melodic parts.
Midierror/agoraphobia(+)
What a lovely mood, great percussion bits here and there, fxs as well. Shame the track has almost zero spatial information, everything is dead center. Its like the track has one dimension less.
Msymiakos/UnfurnishedJungle
Very solid jungle tune, nothing more to say here.
PowieffAcodreon/EmptyRoom
Hard to pinpoint on this pusty pokój ;), it feels really weird and unique…so in that terms its a good job.
Reagae/FillWithWhat
Funny Really liked the creative use of vocals. Im not much of a fan of amen breaks but It was chopped in interesting ways in some parts.
Redman/v9[HerosEnd]
Nicely chopped drums, acid parts were pretty cool too.
Redpanda13/Somebody’sHere
Interesting intro and gated instruments, almost sounding like vocals sometimes.
Sodiufas/Nightwanker
The main nostalgic melodic theme is pretty good.
GhisMart/AloneInTheDark
Great use of speechsynts. Some arrangement parts were pretty interesting, with speed changing etc.
Stailer/NewCityNewLife
Pretty nice composition, has epicness written all over it.
TheBellows/Refurnish
Drums are pretty strong in this one. I liked the many many variations.
TwoThreeZero/RoomListener(+)
My favourite from the experimental ones. It builds atmosphere very well, the pacing is great, on top of great sound design.
Uilome1/Alternate
One of the few relaxed/easy listening tunes in this competition :). Pretty good synth arpeggios, the whole track sets me in a contemplative mood.
YuryKvasha/theordenofelectrosidea
I like the transitions between breakbeat and 4/4 beats. The whole track feels a little too repetitive.There is no actual bassline here, I feel like it would benefit greatly this tune.