Vibe-coded DAW including a tracker view

Hi,
here is a vibe coded DAW which actually seems to look quite solid (didn’t try it yet). Comes already with a lot of solid base features, but the interesting part is: It also provides a tracker view.

What do you think?

1 Like

This feels like a duplicate of another thread, where I put some of my thoughts:

1 Like

not solid, trash UX, terrible worflow, totally pointless especially in morning

instant Uninstall, i never ever see such a bad “daw”

1 Like

Did you try it? At least in the videos, it looks quite clean and intuitive. The tracker seems to be only for the internal chiptune synths, how boring…

I image a DAW like Renoise + Aodix + Bitwig :laughing: Gogogo!

1 Like

I don’t make music in the morning. I will ask Claude to make me Goodnight Tracker.

2 Likes

yes i try it

You say vibe coded (which ironically dismisses any actual human agent and defames the quality of the work), but the author of this software is actually a well-established programmer with a long history going back to C64. He has addressed the use of AI on KVR and elsewhere repeatedly.

4 Likes

Cool, i figured that they had roots in the early computer scene with all the included chipsynths. :slight_smile:

morning daw
classic demoscene sine scroller on the about page

3 Likes

It’s not even moving the vertical parts, but the whole letters instead … Lame! :laughing: Just a joke, it’s quite nice to see that.

2 Likes

BTW, if you want a DAW with a tracker view, see the Ardour Tracker Editor. It is not (yet) included into Ardour but it is already super functional (I’m composing all my music with it). You need to compile it yourself for now though. But I’m happy to help you if you need to.

BTW, almost all of it has been coded by hand (and brain), but I’ve introduced a coding assistant in my work flow for the past month.

6 Likes

This looks interesting! I definitely have to give it a try at some point.

Before that, however, I plan to test MorningDAW v. 1.6.6, which was released today and finally adds the LPB setting I’ve long been wanting to the tracker view.

I’ve just tried MorningDAW. The tracker view is dope, better than my Ardour Tracker Editor in many respects, though probably worse in some others. For instance the LPB in my tracker editor does not need to quantize, instead there is a delay column, and if a cell becomes too crowded it is represented as ***. Of course that should be easy to vibe code, if wanted.

1 Like

I thought MorningDAW looks fantastic, and is amazing for free. How far we have come since the days of Psycle and Buzz, when we were grateful for not-so-great but free music software.

The developer of MorningDAW is adding new stuff every week, and I think it looks beautiful too.

1 Like

Bro is ruthless :laughing:

I’m curious what makes everyone on here try every “new” free DAW out there instead of sticking to the awesome piece of software that all got us on this forum: Renoise.

Is it just curiosity ? lacking stuff on Renoise ?
Genuinely wondering lol

2 Likes

I find the topic interesting in general. As a coder, using AI as a helper tool can indeed increase your capabilities by a lot. On the other hand, it can go wrong, as seen in the AI slop waves. You have to know exactly what you are doing, give exact orders, and review code. The more precise your orders, the better the result will be. If you then feed in specific, well-structured, context-related code, it will kind of understand what your are looking for (tested with Opus 5.5 and DeepSeek 4.1).

In this specific case the amount of new features makes it interesting. In the end you can’t skip the audit and constant refactoring process which comes with developing a daw - a project which usually takes years. I am not sure about the devs of the Morning DAW: Some people say, it’s kind of good slop, others say there are experienced developers behind it.The face of the project in the videos is a musician, not a coder, as far as I know.

The main goal should be that the AI generates human-readable code. Human-readable means: The most simple structure, well named, established design-patterns, understandable for all team members. Very quickly AI turns it into a mess. Projects where no one is able to understand complex code will fail.

Perhaps Renoise could also benefit from AI. Maybe using a local AI only (didn’t test). One thing that is clear about using AI: All code you feed in will turn into “open source”, or even closed source, regardless of the contract details. They are specifically aiming for experienced coders feeding in good algorithms and structures. Very likely your idea will pop up in a session of some other user. I even saw an effect, if you feed in high quality, advanced stuff, and solve complex problems where the AI failed, your current credit suddenly will not run out, the credit usage slows down for some reason… ( :eye:⃤ ).

P.S. My english is so bad.

Very clear answer, thanks a lot ! (and don’t worry about your English, I’m not native but it’s 100% clear).

About Renoise benefiting from AI, I’m pretty sure the devs are using AI already in their workflow, since as you may know as a dev yourself, AI is pretty much everywhere (not vibe-coding per-se, but every developer is at least improving its workflow with AI nowadays).
Also, Renoise being a pretty old project, that must be pretty massive to maintain, I’m sure they use it carefully though and we shouldn’t expect big AI-only features coming soon, since I’m pretty sure taktik (which, from my knowledge is the only real active dev working on Renoise) wants (or needs, imo) to keep a full vision over the whole software and its architecture.

1 Like

Yep, there are no plans to turn Renoise into a vibe coded app with brand new, shiny yet mostly untested features every week - just because you can. We always have selected and built features carefully, and will continue doing so. There are plenty of new tools and new DAWs to choose from now, that can fill this gap. So I think everyone wins here and can get the tool he wants now. Which is overwhelming, yes, but also great.

That said, I think Morning DAW is an exception here, too. It’s fast built, maxing out what’s possible now with AI, but the people behind it seem to know what they are doing and have experience in audio development, which also isn’t the usual case right now.

12 Likes

I’m quite selective when it comes to trying out different DAWs (I mainly use Renoise, Ableton, Bitwig, and now MorningDAW).

What immediately appealed to me about MorningDAW is how the tracker view integrates (fairly) seamlessly with the arrangement view. It allows me to easily view and edit the structures of longer songs without being limited or slowed down by fixed pattern sizes. Furthermore, I can jump to any point in a song and edit it at the note level within the tracker view—a workflow that has become second nature to me over the years using different Soundtracker programs.

It will be interesting to see how the software evolves from here. At this stage, it is incredibly fast and lightweight (a major plus—the installation package is only 25.5 MB!).

For me, this program is a godsend; I’ve long been making music by syncing Renoise and Ableton, and MorningDAW gives me the best of both worlds in a single application.