Bug? Note volume/velocity still changes note volume with VEL→VOL disabled when combined with GX/GXX glide

[protman]

Brief description
Volume/velocity changes note volume with VEL→VOL disabled when combined with GX/GXX glide
This causes conflicts if wanting to use a Velocity Tracker device and GX/GXX glide on the same note without affecting note volume.

Steps to reproduce
Disable VEL→VOL on instrument keyzone. Combine volume and glide commands on same note. Volume changes are heard when glide is used. No volume change is heard when volume command used without glide.

Expected results
No note volume change

Actual results
Volume of note changes

Renoise 3.3.2 / Windows 10

20210723-protman-rn3.3.2-vol-and-glide-with-VEL-to-VOL-disabled.xrns (12.3 KB)

video demo

glide with vel to vol disabled

[taktik]

Sorry for the very late reply.

This is desired behaviour, as a volume command for an already playing sample should always change the volume, even when the “VEL > VOL” option is disabled.

Else you could not do something like this:

C-4 01 ..
--- .. ..
--- .. ..
--- .. 20 < lower volume of the playing sample

with samples which have “VEL > VOL” mapping disabled.