confused with VST plug windows "staying open" when closed

for some reason, vst plugins will stay open post being closed. why don’t they vanish?

also, is there no way to keep playing notes when tweaking something in the external vstplugin window?

7788 Screen Shot 2017-12-16 at 23.41.33.png

cos it feels like if i have clicked on an external plugin window, the keyboard is disabled instead of leaking into renoise. really annoying.

Not sure why the window doesn’t go away - I’m assuming that you’re simply clicking the little “X” in the corner?

What version of OS(x) are you running?

Regarding the key-focus - there’s a little hint in the plugin window itself: “No focus options for bridged plugins”.

You can choose whether to forward key-presses to Renoise or not, but it doesn’t work when running them bridged.

danoise, I already reported this many times now. A lot of bridged plugins do not work properly gui wise anymore in macos. Since 10.11 or so - so for a long time now. I really wonder why you never heard of this before? Didn’t you read my bug reports?

FYI bitwig support says (also some 32 bit stuff not working anymore, but less than in Renoise), that the vst vendor has to fix their gui code for macos compatibility. Studio One in fact seems to blacklist some of those plugins now.

I am not sure if that is true. Most plugins work correctly in macos 10.9.

You can still use those plugins in non-gui mode.

So, if it is not fixable from Renoise side, is it possible to block the plugin gui opening with an additional entry/column in the plugin database? Since sometimes you still will open that gui, because you forgot that it does not work anymore. Then the gui process seems to hang, Renoise won’t quit properly anymore.

danoise, this has been ongoing since at least 10.11 and maybe 10.10. it’s a longstanding bug and my workaround has been to never open any VST plugins, just use audio unit plugins. but some plugins are VST only, and then i’m screwed.

so what’s the solution, please?

I already reported this many times now. A lot of bridged plugins do not work properly gui wise anymore in macos.

I know - it’s also why I needed some confirmation of the OS version.

But you’re saying it’s so bad that some DAWs have chosen to blacklist plugins? Wow, that’s a pretty extreme measure to take.

@esaruoho: you could try running as non-bridged plugins / using audio-unit (au) versions. Not using the bridge should also allow keyboard focus, as you requested.

I know - it’s also why I needed some confirmation of the OS version.

But you’re saying it’s so bad that some DAWs have chosen to blacklist plugins? Wow, that’s a pretty extreme measure to take.

@esaruoho: you could try running as non-bridged plugins / using audio-unit (au) versions. Not using the bridge should also allow keyboard focus, as you requested.

hi, how do i “not use the bridge”?

hi, how do i “not use the bridge”?

I believe you need to

  • run the same bit-version of Renoise as the plugins (32 or 64)

  • make sure “sandboxing” is disabled in preferences > Plug/Misc

But, none of this is ideal of course.

Let me try to consult with taktik and provide a definitive answer for how to deal with this mess?

(hoping we won’t start blacklisting plugins as a consequence…)

*** make sure “sandboxing” is disabled in preferences > Plug/Misc**

But, none of this is ideal of course.

Let me try to consult with taktik and provide a definitive answer for how to deal with this mess?

(hoping we won’t start blacklisting plugins as a consequence…)

Hi, seems like sandboxing fixed this. Now I’m running Syntorus in 64bit mode, with keyboard access. However, I use a ton of legacy 32-bit plugins from old times of yore, and am finding difficulties with my workflow due to them stealing keyboard focus.

I’ve opened a secondary thread in the API forum to try and query about how to both load a plugin/effect, and return keyboard focus back to Renoise, but so far to no avail. (and the thread started with me attempting to use LUA scripting to set disk browser focus).

https://forum.renoise.com/t/set-focus-to-disk-browser-or-to-pattern-editor-globally/48630