Track comment device (mockup)

Hi, I have a feeling this have been suggested before, or maybe it was a tool of some sort back in the day… could not find it now. Anyway - I’d really love to have a (native, preferrably) device like this:

Renoise-forum-track-comment-ideav2

Yay?

EDIT: And I guess there would be no need for an enable/disable switch like in the mockup of course

1 Like

I mean… They have this for the whole song – why not use that and just write “track 1: needs eq”?

Well, yes but the Song Comments can turn messy pretty quickly if you have a lot of notes and it’s not so instantly visible and reachable as it would be with a track comment device. With a dedicated track comment device you could move it next to a very compex part of the chain to explain easily what’s really going on etc.

Not something that everybody would use so much, but I think it could be very useful for some, I know I would use it a lot :slight_smile:

2 Likes

aside from song comments, these are useful…
Screen Shot 2022-03-25 at 9.06.50 AM
kinda has to be short and sweet and to-the-point, though

BUT, you could always use the formula device if you want a place for comments!!
Screen Shot 2022-03-25 at 9.24.27 AM

4 Likes

Someone wrote a tool for track comments that used the song comments area as a demarcated text area.

I glommed that and made my own tool for track/pattern comments

It exploits the fact that Renoise will ignore fx column entries it doesn’t recognize. This allowed me to have a comment for each pattern in a track (if I wanted), which is handy when I want to add note on something there.

I haven’t really done much with this since writing it but some may find it useful or interesting.

2 Likes

@James_Britt
Hey, wow yes those were the tools I had way back in my memory, thanks!

I tried them both now and they do almost what I’m after. The only big downside for my needs with these is that they are too «hidden» and not instantly visible / accessable, but I guess it’s not possible with the current api to make them appear in the track dsp chain like in my mockup (?). I’m no LUA-head so I have no clue :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

@slujr
Thanks for the formula device tip! yes that’s the closest I’ll get at the moment I guess :slight_smile: I’ll try to use those for my purposes, I just have to learn to ignore the sliders etc on the left side :innocent:

2 Likes