Where do you get that from?The only thing i really see anyone against on these forums is a piano roll.
There is threads full of feature requests from users on here.A lot of features get implemented over the years.
2 Likes
Well, let’s hope that by 2055 Renoise implements my suggestions! I’m also in the queue (it’s not piano roll I swear). 
1 Like
What suggestion have you made that people don’t like?
Me? None (I think). People are allowed to like or disliked suggestions, the real problem here seems to be people being gaslighted when they decide to express their experiences with Renoise and when they suggest feature updates or performance fixes. It’s not uncommon to see someone complain about performance issues followed by replies trying to disregard their experience, it happened to me, it happened with friends… it’s even an internal joke among my group of fellas. This honestly helps no one (quite the opposite) and serves only to feed one’s ego. As I said before, this happens to some extent in every forum (gatekeepers are everywhere) but this one really stands out.
2 Likes
I guess some ppl have had a very traumatic experience with piano rolls 
I’m just joking btw.
If I had to say my top realistic feature request though, it would be MORE keyboard shortcut options. I know I’m being greedy though
Any examples?
1 Like
Following the spirit of this thread (plans for renoise), my only two big requests are more granular parameters in the sampler and performance fixes, especially related to VST3.
On the top of my head I remember the thread where the guy suggested a dancing sprite, I also remember people doing this on at least two of my support requests. I don’t think you’re unaware of what I’m speaking about.
In fairness the dancing sprite was retarded.
5 Likes
I don’t think it’s fair to call people’s suggestions “retarded” or discredit them simply based on one’s subjective feelings about it, without providing any further contribution to the topic at hand (if there’s no contribution to be given, why comment on the first place?), especially given the fact that OP was extremely thorough and polite with their request. Literally no reason to do that, it only discourages people of engaging here (which was the case).
Life is not fair dude, is there any suggestions other than a dancing sprite and piano roll, that were poo-poo’d?
3 Likes
I know I’m in the minority here, but I now legitimately want a breakdancing 16-bit green piano troll 
Plus @moloko you actually came out swinging in that thread iirc. It wasn’t all reasoned discussion and sensible suggestions on anyone’s part in that thread, but the second comment was a practical suggestion to DIY it, which is surely in keeping with the spirit of the DAW. Yes, there are strong opinions expressed here, and not always gently, but would you have it another way? Surely you want to be able to speak your own mind with as much directness as you wish, no?
Thread in question if anyone wants a refresher
3 Likes
Can you imagine if everybody’s suggestions were implemented into Renoise, what a mess!
I legitimately want a calculator inside renoise, also a retarded suggestion, it will never happen.
Probably for the best. 
Classic thread. That TNT guy was not having any of it. I love the juxtaposition of his smiling face and the rage expressed in his comments, gives me a chuckle.
2 Likes
Lol yes, he’s not one to mince words…
Like, tell us how you really feel, man
Life isn’t fair but why can’t we be fair from time to time? That’s no excuse.
I followed the whole thread, OP was polite until people started being rude to them. That thread is a shit show, some people actually gave insightful suggestions on the topic (cheers to them), other people were just there to shit on the suggestion. Speaking one’s one mind is important, not being rude to people is also important.
1 Like
I actually thought the original post was kind of snotty.
And actually reading his reply suggests that the original post was in fact snotty. So i mean, tough, he got back what he put out!
So starting a ridiculous thread about some dancing piece of shit with a snotty tone, i mean you’re basically asking to be insulted.
That’s a ridiculous thread to back up your statement with btw.
I tend to agree. And generally, people tend to get back what they put out. I’ve mostly found this forum to be very helpful and generous when I’ve had questions or needed help, but ymmv
1 Like
Calculator - you already have, kind of. Activate the Tools Developer console. Try for example:
>>> x=math.sin(20)
>>> print(x)
0.91294525072763
1 Like